Auto logout in seconds.
Continue LogoutHealth systems often grapple with crisis situations that challenge the resiliency of frontline clinicians. Chronic exposure to stressful environments can leave health care workers physically and emotionally drained. With a renewed focus on staff resiliency, health systems need to implement systems to accurately help leaders take a pulse on clinicians’ well-being. Leaders need to identify when a team or individual employee needs support and what structural barriers they face that overly complicate their work.
1. Children’s Mercy Hospital is a 367-bed pediatric medical center in Kansas City, Missouri, United States, that focuses on care for patients from birth to age 21.
2. Coxa Hospital for Joint Replacement is a 64-bed hospital in Tampere, Finland.
These progressive organizations created house-wide stoplight assessments to foster the well-being of their workforce. Using these assessments, leaders can identify individual clinicians or teams that need additional emotional support and direct them to resources that will help support their well-being. In addition, leaders can identify and modify processes or situations that negatively impact staff resilience.
This approach of including stoplight assessments in the workflow is a highly effective strategy for identifying clinicians who need additional support or that face structural challenges that needlessly complicate their work. The initial investment of time to design and implement these processes allowed health systems to collect real-time data that executive leaders and managers can use to act on problems as they occur.
Frontline staff are frequently exposed to a variety of emotionally charged scenarios and are particularly susceptible to feeling like they don’t have time for emotional recovery. They almost always prioritize patient needs over their own well-being and are hesitant to ask for help, opting into the culture of “I’m fine.” In this context, Children’s Mercy and Coxa Hospital both knew they had to proactively assess the emotional capacity of staff in a safe environment, as opposed to taking a passive or reactive approach.
Both organizations started by developing stoplight assessment tools to help leaders identify challenges in real time. Children’s Mercy deploys their assessment at the start of team huddles while Coxa implements theirs at the end of each clinician’s shift.
A key ingredient in these initiatives is the way each organization paired the results of the data with actionable next steps. Children’s Mercy designed pathways that allow managers and team leaders to connect their employees with resilience and well-being resources that the organization provides. Leaders at Coxa review their real-time data on a daily, weekly, and monthly basis to identify and address the root causes of problems that require leadership’s attention.
While there are multiple ways to implement stoplight assessments, we will look at the variations that Children’s Mercy and Coxa used.
Psychologists at Mercy Children’s Hospital created a four-color well-being tracker for leaders to score their team’s stress levels. Clinical team leaders can use scores from the survey to inform their decision to request additional support for their staff. This system operates with 3 main components.
Component 1: Implement stoplight assessment during team meetings
Children’s Mercy developed an anonymous well-being survey that team leaders can routinely use to assess the overall stress level of the team. Clinicians record their feelings as green, yellow, orange, or red, representing a spectrum from low to high stress through a digital survey. The goal of the assessment is not to single out staff members who are struggling. Instead, it’s meant to get a quantitative sense of how each team is coping overall so team leaders can activate organizational support resources as necessary.
Component 2: Translate survey data into actionable next steps
To make the data easy to digest, each color corresponds to a numerical value: green is coded as 1, yellow as 2, orange as 3, and red as 4. When staff complete the survey, team leaders automatically receive a single “team stress index” that is an average of each member’s response. An index score of 1.5 or higher may indicate a high level of team stress, and leaders are encouraged to leverage the organization’s emotional support resources.
Component 3: Activate well-being resources
Children’s Mercy paired their well-being tracker with a series of scoped resources that leaders can leverage to support their teams. Via the institution’s intranet, team leaders can submit an electronic request for a wellness representative to join their next team huddle to facilitate stress reduction exercises. They can also separately request a virtual support group specifically for their team. Beyond these two targeted support pathways, team leaders can direct their staff to the organization’s employee wellness resource page, which is regularly updated with additional well-being resources such as a 24/7 chaplainled inspiration line, one-on-one support with clinical social workers, guided meditations, and relaxation rooms.
Results
Children’s Mercy piloted their well-being survey in May 2020 in four areas: neurology, cardiology, developmental and behavioral, and one non-clinical discipline. They've already seen promising results, including an increase in staff utilization of well-being resources. Leaders attribute this, in part, to the fact that well-being is a standard agenda item for interdisciplinary team huddles. Overwhelmingly, the feedback from the front line to the executive level has been enthusiastic, with managers articulating their appreciation for a transparent way to assess their team’s well-being.
Supporting artifact

In 2009, Coxa Hospital for Joint Replacement in Finland deployed a tool they call Pulssi (Finnish for “pulse”) to assess staff’s emotional capacity on a per-shift basis. Data from the Pulssi tool is evaluated by nursing leaders and unit managers on a regular basis to address areas of concern that require additional attention. Their approach involves three components.
Component 1: Implement Pulssi assessment
Pulssi was created to quantitatively unify subjective experience evaluations with hard indicators. During the few minutes before the end of each shift, frontline clinicians can reflect on their day and record their answers with color-coded options. Pulssi responses are categorized into green (strong well-being), yellow, and red (poor well-being). Yellow and red responses require a short comment on what went poorly during the shift.
Component 2: Escalate Pulssi data to instigate problem-solving process
Unit managers and the director of nursing review the combined data on a daily, weekly, and monthly basis. They meet with staff to discuss significant patterns, assess underlying root causes, and address areas of concern that require attention. Managers are trained to facilitate open and blame-free discussions to engage frontline staff to work together to find solutions to common challenges identified through Pulssi.
Component 3: Implement solutions for root-cause problems
Collection of Pulssi data drew leaders’ attention to problems as soon as staff identified them. By quickly bringing staff and leaders together to respond to the challenge, Coxa ensures that isolated issues do not escalate into larger problems over time.
Results
Coxa reported that Pulssi gave leaders a comprehensive measurement of clinician well-being and led to remarkable changes in the organization’s culture of resilience. Previously, clinicians had a tendency to withhold emotions and blame leaders for frustrations that inevitably occur in daily work. Now, staff feel open and comfortable sharing their feelings and brainstorming solutions. Additionally, recording their responses at the end of their shift allows clinicians to process their feelings. It puts an ends an end to their day, and they can begin their next shift with a fresh outlook.
Supporting artifact


Create your free account to access 1 resource, including the latest research and webinars.
You have 1 free members-only resource remaining this month.
1 free members-only resources remaining
1 free members-only resources remaining
You've reached your limit of free insights
Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you.
You've reached your limit of free insights
Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you.
This content is available through your Curated Research partnership with Advisory Board. Click on ‘view this resource’ to read the full piece
Email ask@advisory.com to learn more
Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you.
This is for members only. Learn more.
Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you.