What you need to know about the forces reshaping our industry.


October 25, 2021

'Bullying, intimidation, and harassment': How Covid-19 skeptics are wearing down public health officials

Daily Briefing

    Coordinated protests from Covid-19 skeptics have pushed many public health professionals out of their jobs, Kirk Siegler reports for NPR—and these skeptics may soon begin targeting these vacated positions for themselves.

    Radio Advisory: Aaron Carroll on how clinicians can combat medical misinformation

    Public health workers are being driven away

    According to a New York Times analysis, more than 500 top health officials across the country have left their positions in the last 19 months amid prolonged stress and increasing animosity from the public.

    For example, Diana Lachiondo, a former commissioner and health board officer in Ada County, Idaho, said an "angry mob" tried to break into a meeting of the state's Central Health District board after some members expressed support for preventive Covid-19 measures, such as extending mask mandates, Siegler reports. After that, several protesters also gathered outside of her house, screaming and banging pots.

    Nick Lawyer, a PA and former county public health officer in Sanders County, Montana, faced "a coordinated campaign of harassment" after he wrote an op-ed encouraging people to get vaccinated against Covid-19 for several small-town newspapers. In September, an elderly local activist blamed Lawyer for his 82-year-old wife's death from Covid-19, calling him a "petty tyrant," Siegler writes.

    "I never met her," Lawyer said. "I actually never provided her any care. But her husband blames me for her death saying that I put up barriers to her receiving unproven measures like ivermectin and other treatments."

    Lawyer, ultimately was asked to resign after angry protestors disrupted several county commissioner meetings, Siegler writes.

    The 'play book' for Covid-19 skeptics

    According to Siegler, far-right groups started recruiting and organizing members in rural areas, where there is longstanding antigovernment sentiment, early on in the pandemic to protest against lockdowns that were being implemented.

    "In some cases, people are much more afraid of their perceived government overreach than they are of the virus," Lachiondo said.

    Travis McAdam, an extremism expert at the Montana Human Rights Network, said these groups have developed a "play book" on how to disrupt local meetings and antagonize public health officials, Siegler writes. "They're using bullying, intimidation, and harassment as political tools," McAdam said.

    Part of what makes these groups so effective is their online organization and ability to quickly mobilize, Siegler writes. For instance, dark money groups have made training and social media tools readily available online, enabling organizers to quickly alert activists about new meetings or protests through text alerts or Facebook groups.

    Now, some groups are changing their strategies, McAdam said. Instead of just organizing protests, certain groups have moved toward running for political office or trying to gain positions on health boards and other local organizations, Siegler writes.

    Because of this, Lachiondo said she is worried qualified people will no longer want to serve in public health positions. "That is incredibly sad but also scary because then you're left with, who does step up and what are their aims and motivations if they aren't altruistic," she said.

    In addition, Lawyer said the anti-science and anti-expert sentiment he was currently seeing in Montana was "chilling," Siegler writes. "However genuine in the effort to preserve individual choice and individual right, when we politicize and marginalize expert opinion, that will certainly further push us down the road of fascism," he said. (Siegler, NPR, 10/20)

    Aaron Carroll on how clinicians can combat medical misinformation

    Listen to the Radio Advisory episode

    Radio Advisory, a podcast for busy health care leaders.

    Medical misinformation has been a significant problem for a long time, but amid the Covid-19 pandemic, the problem has become even more widespread. In this episode, host Rachel Woods sits down with Dr. Aaron Carroll, author, professor, and Indiana University chief health officer—to discuss what all clinicians should do to combat medical misinformation.

    Plus, Advisory Board experts Solomon Banjo and Pam Divack offer their take on clinician’s role in online spaces (with patients and with each other) and translate those same principles for the rest of the industry.

    Listen now

    Have a Question?


    Ask our experts a question on any topic in health care by visiting our member portal, AskAdvisory.