Report

9 minute read

Meeting out-of-industry digital experiences

5 essential components of a strong digital experience

Health care has long wanted to adopt the digital consumer experiences of banking, retail, and entertainment. However, health care has fallen short of that goal—often citing the unique difficulties of the industry.

Health care leaders should adopt a leapfrog strategy and take advantage of the lessons learned from its out-of-industry counterparts. Read on for the five components of a digital experience health care can adopt from other industries.


The conventional wisdom

Health care leaders want to meet consumers’ rising expectations for digital experiences—the types of experiences consumers are accustomed to in all other aspects of their lives, like banking, retail, and entertainment.. But even for motivated, progressive leaders, it can seem impossible for health care to meet the expectations that out-of-industry players have set.

Health care is too different from other industries.

Health care leaders often defend poor digital experiences, arguing that health care is too different from other industries. Here are the three common excuses we hear.

  • The rules of consumerism don’t apply to health care. There’s not the same level of choice, transparency, or motivation to access digital services in health care as there is in other industries.
  • Health care is too regulated and complex, making it difficult for leaders to implement broad changes while maintaining compliance to policy and regulations.
  • The personal nature of health care makes it difficult to transition to digital experiences, where there could be a loss of connection and empathy.

There are no guideposts for improving the digital experience.

On top of that, there is no clear roadmap on where or how to invest in digital experiences which makes it difficult for health care leaders to:

  • Prioritize solutions. There are many facets to the health care digital experience and leaders struggle to know where to start and how to make the biggest impact.
  • Make the case for ROI. Because the digital experience is multi-faceted and consumers have different preferences, it’s hard to draw a line between investment and return.

Our take

Health care leaders can, and should, aim for out-of-industry digital experiences.

The competitive landscape is everchanging, and health care leaders must meet demand for better experiences or risk falling even further behind in digital transformation.

  • Consumer expectations for digital experiences are rising. According to Cedar, 28% of patients switched their provider because of a poor digital experience. And that experience includes everything from scheduling to virtual visits to billing. People of all demographics have become more technologically savvy and feel empowered now more than ever to take control of their health.
  • Competitors are already improving their digital experiences. Disruptors like One Medical have built their market around patient-centered experiences that include digital capabilities. But it’s not just “disruptors” that are making progress—incumbents have also made moves. A study by PricewaterhouseCoopers found that 81% of health plan executives are investing in technology to improve member experience; and a patient engagement trends survey found that 77% of digital health executives are investing in enhanced portals and mobile apps.

The bottom line: leaders who procrastinate on investment in digital experience will not only be behind other industries but will also be behind their peers in health care.

Health care organizations don’t have to start from scratch.

Health care leaders don’t have to start from scratch when it comes to creating a good digital experience. Consumers have already learned to interact digitally in other aspects of their lives and can bring that skill and knowledge to their interactions with health care.

Leaders can look to other industries, not to mimic their experiences exactly, but to identify what works well and what could apply to health care. They can learn from the failures and successes of other industries as they continue to invest in digital experiences.


Five components of a good digital experience

We’ve identified five components that out-of-industry players prioritize in digital experiences. They are ordered in terms of feasibility to implement and are meant to build off each other.

Functionality refers to the usability and accessibility of a solution. A functional solution will work as intended, requiring minimal effort from the user. Examples of functionality include how long it takes to load a webpage or whether all the menu buttons lead to the correct webpage.

Functional solutions are important to user buy-in. A bad experience that doesn’t work as expected will turn people away and break down a user’s trust in future solutions.

Out-of-industry: Amazon’s “One Click Ordering”

Amazon allows consumers to easily purchase items with the click of a button. The key is that Amazon saves consumers’ credit card and address information so that the consumer doesn’t need to enter information across multiple pages. “One Click Ordering” makes purchasing from Amazon habitual because it’s so easy and frictionless.

Health care example: One Medical’s app-first experience

One Medical is an app-first primary care organization that offers telehealth and in-person care to its members. One Medical designed its digital experience around patients’ anticipated needs. Patients can easily view provider calendars, schedule appointments, renew prescriptions, and communicate with providers. One Medical has made health care intuitive for members, which has driven member retention and engagement with their services. Note: One Medical was recently acquired by Amazon, likely because of their ability to build a functional and easy digital customer experience in the health care space.

Customer service is the ability for an organization to respond quickly, empathetically, and efficiently to consumer challenges. Good customer service is an important element of a good care experience—96% percent of patient complaints in health care are related to customer service, not quality of care.

Health care organizations have adopted chatbots as a common element of customer service strategies. In fact, chat bots will be responsible for $8 billion in savings by 2022. By implementing a digital solution that can handle more straightforward patient questions, staff can respond to more complex questions in a timely manner, resulting in improved customer service.

Out-of-industry example: JPMorgan Chase’s AI virtual assistant

JPMorgan uses an AI-powered virtual assistant to provide real-time support to clients when they have questions or face technology challenges, like resetting a password. The virtual assistant can even provide personalized recommendations to clients based on their frequent actions. Consumers have greater trust in JPMorgan Chase as a result of the timely and personalized support from the virtual assistant.

Health care example: Providence’s AI-powered chatbot

During Covid-19, Providence launched Grace, their AI-powered chatbot, to provide real-time care navigation and customer service. With Grace, patients can share their symptoms and schedule same-day or next-day appointments, receive patient education, and be directed to their nearest clinic. Basically, Grace plays the part of an efficient and informative contact center representative so that patients can get the quality service they want.

Data spotlight
42%

Of patients were able to get help answering their questions or help navigating to the right care

18%

Of patient engagement with Grace resulted in completed appointments with an ExpressCare Clinic

40%

Of patients said that Grace met their needs after their interaction

Self-service refers to a customer’s ability to solve their own problems, make decisions, and perform tasks autonomously. Within health care, self-service often looks like shifting administrative tasks to patients who prefer completing them at their own convenience, which can ease the administrative burden for the organization.

Out-of-industry example: JPMorgan Chase’s online banking

The banking industry is a leader in self-service. As an example, JPMorgan Chase allows consumers to manage their checking and saving accounts, deposit checks, and transfer money through the app without having to call or talk to a representative. Customers find this service extremely appealing—47 million customers use JPMorgan Chase’s online banking services, with an average of 15 or more logins per month.

Health care example: Cedar’s self-service billing features

From pre-service to post-billing, Cedar makes it easy for patients to stay on top of their medical bills. The solutions provide patients with financial options prior to care and allows patients to input information like insurance documents, eliminating duplicative information requests. A benefits tracker allows patients to see how much a service will cost and when their deductibles will be met. Most importantly, patients can easily pay their bills through Cedar’s app or website. By shifting some of the tasks to patients (especially things like bill pay, which patients manage in other industries), Cedar help their health care clients improve patient satisfaction, while also increasing efficiency and generating cost savings.

Data spotlight
42%

Increase in ApolloMD’s collection rates after partnering with Cedar

23%

Increase in West Tennessee Healthcare’s collection rates after partnering with Cedar

212%

Increase in West Tennessee Healthcare’s digital payments after partnering with Cedar

Personalization offers consumers customized experiences based on factors such as their demographic data, engagement, location, and articulated needs. In practice, companies target tailored content to consumers based on their user profile.

Data shows that 72% of consumers will only engage with personalized messaging and that 93% of companies with a personalization strategy have experienced an increase in revenue. In health care, personalization is especially poised to help better activate and engage patients. Personalization shows patients that health care organizations are attempting to holistically understand each patient as a person and that they are willing to invest in their needs.

Out-of-industry example: Netflix’s “taste communities”

Netflix uses consumer engagement data to provide personalized content recommendations. However, instead of developing individual content suggestions for its millions of users, which would be resource-intensive, Netflix aggregated its consumer data to develop “taste communities” where consumers with similar content preferences are grouped together. These groups then receive similar messaging and content recommendations, driving viewer engagement and streams.

Health care example: Oscar Health Plan’s messaging campaign

Oscar Health Plan selectively targets almost 200 messaging campaigns to specific members based on their communication preferences (via text, email, or phone call) and demographic data. For example, individuals who opt-in to share their sexual orientation with Oscar receive tailored messaging about the benefits that best pertain to them. The personalized messaging helps prevent information overload and information fatigue, while keeping patients engaged in their own care.

Data spotlight
20%

Increase in member engagement driven by personalized messaging

40%

Increase in the volume of campaigns targeting member

Omnichannel experiences provide consumers the same high-quality experience across multiple channels, both digital and in-person. Allowing consumers to move seamlessly from digital to in-personal channels is essential to retaining consumers and keeping them happy. Data suggests 40% of consumers won’t do business with an organization if they can’t use their preferred channel.

Omnichannel experiences in health care are vital in an increasingly hybrid care world, and can improve patient satisfaction and communication between providers, caregivers, and patients. Some examples of channels a patient might move through in health care include: chatbots, appointment scheduling, telehealth, portals, and online bill payment, and in-person visits.

Out-of-industry example: Amazon

Amazon customers have the same quality shopping experience whether they purchase on the website, the app, through Alexa, or in stores. By providing an omnichannel experience, Amazon embeds itself in customers’ day-to-day and allows customers to access Amazon’s platform wherever they are and however they want.

Health care example: Walgreens’ “Find Care” platform

Walgreens’ “Find Care” digital platform allows patients a seamless experience across its pharmacy, retail, and health care offerings. Customers can request a virtual or in-person visit via the app and website. They can scan their medicine bottle through their phone to trigger a refill that they can then pick up in a store. Walgreens’ various partnerships with provider organizations make this seamless experience from digital platforms to brick-and-mortar stores possible.

Most health care organizations, including Walgreens, are still experimenting with omnichannel experiences as relatively new offerings. We expect that more organizations will explore omnichannel solutions in the wake of the widespread adoption of virtual and hybrid care that we saw during the pandemic.


Parting thoughts

The goal for health care leaders is to implement each component into a cohesive digital experience for patients. Creating a digital experience is not a quick fix. But using these components as building blocks will help health care organizations work towards the strong digital experiences that other industries offer.

One last thing: consider how these components will impact all stakeholders, not just patients

Investments to improve digital consumer experiences impact all stakeholders, not just patients. Providers, plans, and other health care organizations will have better experiences as these components are implemented. For example, self-service can decrease the administrative burden for staff and omnichannel experiences can make it easier for providers and plans to manage patients across their care journeys.

At the same time, the implementation of these components will require stakeholders to accept and adopt a new way of providing health care. As always, stakeholder buy-in is crucial to a successful project. Leaders should include other stakeholders throughout implementation of these components and provide training on changes to backend processes and workflows.

Ultimately, a good experience for all stakeholders will translate to a better experience for patients.


Downloads

SPONSORED BY

INTENDED AUDIENCE

AFTER YOU READ THIS

AUTHORS

TOPICS

INDUSTRY SECTORS

Don't miss out on the latest Advisory Board insights

Create your free account to access 1 resource, including the latest research and webinars.

Want access without creating an account?

   

You have 1 free members-only resource remaining this month.

1 free members-only resources remaining

1 free members-only resources remaining

You've reached your limit of free insights

Become a member to access all of Advisory Board's resources, events, and experts

Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you.

Benefits include:

Unlimited access to research and resources
Member-only access to events and trainings
Expert-led consultation and facilitation
The latest content delivered to your inbox

You've reached your limit of free insights

Become a member to access all of Advisory Board's resources, events, and experts

Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you.

Benefits include:

Unlimited access to research and resources
Member-only access to events and trainings
Expert-led consultation and facilitation
The latest content delivered to your inbox

This content is available through your Curated Research partnership with Advisory Board. Click on ‘view this resource’ to read the full piece

Email ask@advisory.com to learn more

Click on ‘Become a Member’ to learn about the benefits of a Full-Access partnership with Advisory Board

Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you. 

Benefits Include:

Unlimited access to research and resources
Member-only access to events and trainings
Expert-led consultation and facilitation
The latest content delivered to your inbox

This is for members only. Learn more.

Click on ‘Become a Member’ to learn about the benefits of a Full-Access partnership with Advisory Board

Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you. 

Benefits Include:

Unlimited access to research and resources
Member-only access to events and trainings
Expert-led consultation and facilitation
The latest content delivered to your inbox
AB
Thank you! Your updates have been made successfully.
Oh no! There was a problem with your request.
Error in form submission. Please try again.