Case Study

9 minute read

How Hywel Dda Hardwired Flexibility into Strategic Planning

Learn how one organization hardwired flexibility into strategic planning to keep up with today's rapidly changing environment.

Overview

The challenge

Covid-19 made strategic planning and decision-making difficult because the disease was new, health systems had little information about it, and executives needed to make decisions quickly and prioritize those decisions rigorously. After adopting “pandemic response” frameworks, leaders realized that previous planning and decision-making structures were inefficient given today's rapidly changing environment. Now, leaders are struggling to hardwire the flexibility they achieved during the pandemic into their strategic planning processes.

The organization

Hywel Dda University Health Board is a publicly funded integrated care system serving 384,000 people in Midwest Wales, U.K. It is part of NHS Wales. The system funds and manages acute, primary, community, mental health, and dental care, as well as services for people with disabilities across its provider sites.

The approach

Hywel Dda took four steps to revamp both its strategic framework and its process for setting strategy. They audited and reorganized their previous strategic plans to eliminate overlap of old mandates. They added flexibility to their strategic planning mindset and created two teams to constantly scan the environment for variables that would affect their long-term plans. They hardwired a lighter-touch governance structure developed during Covid-19 that puts non-executives in critical roles to deliver against new objectives.

The result

The new strategic framework was well-received across Hywel Dda’s executive teams. The changes made to how they think and talk about strategic planning, and the associated process changes, now allow the organization to respond to environmental pressures quickly and tweak their long-term plans as needed. These changes increased autonomy and accountability of leaders at the board, executive, and unit levels.


Approach

How Hywel Dda hardwired flexibility into its strategic planning process

In the wake of the Covid-19 pandemic, Hywel Dda's executive team and board created a new strategic framework and decision-making structure that embraces flexibility and agility. The structure enables the system to rapidly respond to emerging pressures and mandates and adjust their strategic priorities accordingly. It also empowers leaders throughout the organization to own and carry out work on any new priorities.


The  Four Steps

The executive team took four steps to create a new strategic framework and decision-making structure capable of rapidly flexing to meet any emerging demand on the health system.

Hywel Dda’s leaders audited all of the system's previous strategic priorities to remove any overlap or obsolescence, and reaffirm the system’s long-term trajectory. The chief executive, with support from the strategy director and the project management office, reviewed 458 strategic “priorities” that had built up, unchecked, since 2017. The priorities fell into three buckets:

  1. Previous strategic recommendations: 2017-20 strategic plan, long-term system transformation plan
  2. One-off recommendations and national guidance: top-down recommendations from the Welsh government, quality assurance targets
  3. Current strategic priorities: the new 2020-23 strategic plan, Covid-19 response requirements

Within this sprawl, the same goals often appeared numerous times in different formats and within different plans, leaving ample room for simplification. Leaders first examined the previous priorities to identify where mandates overlapped. They also checked to see if any goals were no longer relevant and whether they were missing any priorities critical to the pandemic response and recovery. Next, the chief executive and the deputy chief executive (who also serves as the Medical Director) worked with the board to reorganize the priorities into a clearer strategic framework. They challenged each board member to draft their own priority framework based on the audit's results and Hywel Dda’s current challenges. The chief executive and deputy chief executive synthesized Hywel Dda’s new strategic framework out of feedback from the board members. Since the board had given their input throughout the process, they gave their approval shortly after the final version was complete.

As executives designed the strategic framework and consulted with the board, they developed a new way of thinking and talking about system priorities. This narrative reflected the mind-shift executives needed to embrace to ensure flexibility in the organization’s planning process. This narrative has two layers. On top are the broad, aspirational objectives that the organization is continually chasing—its “true north.” Below them are time-bound tactical moves they’ll make in the direction of true north. These tactical moves are time-bound, iterative, and measurable.

Hywel Dda’s chief executive used a sailing metaphor to describe this plan. The organization’s six strategic objectives (its “true north”) are “smudges on the horizon.” Those objectives are ideals rather than specific targets, since the organization should still be moving toward them in three years, five years, or even a decade. Five of the six strategic objectives came from previous cultural values or strategic priorities, meaning that staff and leaders were already familiar with them. The sixth was borne out of a need to conserve resources during and after Covid-19.

Hywel Dda’s six strategic objectives lay out its long-term identity:

  1. Putting people at the heart of everything we do
  2. Working together to be the best we can be
  3. Striving to deliver and develop excellent services
  4. The best health and well-being for our individuals, families, and our communities
  5. Safe, sustainable, accessible, and kind care
  6. Sustainable use of resources

After naming the six, high-level strategic objectives, Hywel Dda drafted 65 tactically oriented “planning objectives” to move the organization toward the strategic objectives over specific time spans. To carry the sailing metaphor further, if the strategic objectives are “smudges on the horizon,” then the 65 planning objectives are the “paddle strokes” that Hywel Dda will make to achieve them. Each planning objective falls under one of the six strategic objectives and has defined metrics and timelines. A single executive director oversees each planning objective by working with managers at the unit, division, and department levels.

This new way of thinking and talking about strategic priorities allowed Hywel Dda to shift from static to dynamic planning. Leaders constantly scan the horizon to see if they need to pivot left or right—update, add, or delete objectives—to keep “sailing” toward their true north.

strategic-objectives-quote

Here are two examples of what this looks like. For the strategic objective “putting people at the heart of everything we do,” there are about a dozen planning objectives (“paddle strokes”) to move in that direction. For instance, one planning objective is to design a training and development program that would build excellent customer service for all staff in public and patient-facing roles, and to have the program running by April 2021.

Another strategic objective is “sustainable use of resources.” One of a paddle stroke under that objective is to develop a plan to make all services carbon neutral by 2030 and begin its implementation within the next three years.

These are just two examples of the 65 concrete goals that Hywel Dda detailed. Achieving each of these goals will bring the organization closer to their strategic objectives—those “smudges on the horizon.”

Being flexible while developing and executing strategy requires continuous monitoring of the operating environment. To ensure the freshest situational analyses, Hywel Dda created two steering groups that constantly scan the environment and bring any new mandates to the board and C-suite. These executives can then add, subtract, or change any of the 65 “paddle stroke” objectives to better steer the ship.

To do this effectively, Hywel Dda divided the analytical responsibilities across two teams. One team scans the broader health care environment to identify emerging pressures and develop novel solutions and approaches to address them. The other team assesses the feasibility and timelines of implementing these new solutions based on resource availability.

Collectively, these two teams provide an efficient funnel for new strategy proposals to flow to the c-suite. The Transformation Steering Group (TSG) operates as the top of the funnel to generate new observations, insights, and plans. And the Strategic Enabling Group (SEG) works as the filter to help the board select the solutions with the highest likelihood of success.

Responsibilities and composition of the TSG-SEG steering group dyad:

1. Transformation Steering Group: Scans the environment for new mandates or external pressures and crafts intelligence-based proposals for new planning objectives. Proposals clarify why the new objective is a priority, and what purpose it serves.

  • Representation from: Chief executive; medical director; board members; and directors of finance and planning, performance, informatics, and commissioning

2. Strategic Enabling Group: Establishes resource requirements and a timeline by which Hywel Dda can achieve new objectives that the TSG proposes. If the timeline and resources necessary are viable, the proposal is sent to the board for a ratification process.

  • Representation from: Procurement and sourcing; capital and estates; workforce, data, and informatics; legal; and finance

When Covid-19 erupted across the U.K., Hywel Dda implemented the NHS’s Command and Control Structure to ensure lockstep across the continuum of care. Hospitals and community organizations typically set up command-and-control structures during disasters to clarify decision-making authority, task ownership, and resource management.

After the first wave of Covid-19, Hywel Dda wanted to translate some of the key elements from the command-and-control structure to their internal decision-making and execution processes. In their new formation, executives approve (or decline) proposals for new planning objectives that the TSG-SEG dyad brings them. Once a planning objective has been approved, the responsibility for implementation is cascaded down to managers and their teams. The rationale is that those closest to the work should be the ones making the changes.

Command-control-quote

Hywel Dda uses a medal nomenclature to describe which parts of the organization have which responsibilities. The gold group (the board and chief executive) ensures the system progressively moves toward their six strategic objectives. They decide if a new planning objective proposal is in service of those six strategic objectives, and thus worth pursuing or not. Once ratified, the gold group passes the new planning objective onto the silver group (executive directors) to create plans to achieve each planning objective. The bronze group (unit/divisional directors) implement these plans and see them through to completion.

group-structure-system


Results

How we know it’s working

Hywel Dda audited and restructured their strategic plan in the middle of a pandemic. The realities of the crisis laid bare the need for change, and the executive team responded promptly. While it’s only been a few months, they have already seen positive, qualitative results. After presenting the new strategic framework to the board, the chief executive said, “There was universal recognition that it was right, it had resonance, people knew and understood the strategic objectives. They could easily grasp these goals.” Because the planning objectives can constantly be re-evaluated and modified by the TSG and SEG, this model enables greater latitude to respond to situational changes. The model gave the board a clear view of the organization’s operating environment, thus making their work in responding to change easier.

The Welsh NHS Confederation requested that each of the seven health boards in Wales capture what they learned in the Covid-19 pandemic. Hywel Dda engaged more than 100 senior leaders through virtual interviews and questionnaires. Feedback on the changes in governance structure included comments like: “There have been reductions in levels of bureaucracy with most comments of this nature praising the increase in pace," and “[Staff felt] greater empowerment with less [need for] support from management/senior leaders.”  Many leaders shared that this structure has shifted the organization’s ethos from corporate accountability (the organization and its executives are “on the hook” for everyone meeting expectations) to personal accountability (each individual has agency to make decisions that will help them meet expectations). This made leaders more accountable to complete their individual action items and showed that they had a clear mandate to do so.


Sources

“Developing the 3 Year Plan for the Period 2021/22 - 2023/24,“ Hywel Dda Board Meeting documents, 24 September 2020; “Strategic Discover Report,” Hywel Dda University Health Board, July 2020; Hywel Dda University Health Board, Wales, UK; Advisory Board interviews and analysis; "Public Board: Maintaining Good GovernanceCOVID-19,” Hywel Dda Board Meeting documents, 30 July 2020.


SPONSORED BY

INTENDED AUDIENCE

AFTER YOU READ THIS

1. You'll learn how to revamp your organization's strategic framework and process for setting strategy.

2. You'll be able to add flexibility to your strategic-planning mindset.


AUTHORS

Paul Trigonoplos

Director, Hospital and health system research

TOPICS

INDUSTRY SECTORS

Don't miss out on the latest Advisory Board insights

Create your free account to access 1 resource, including the latest research and webinars.

Want access without creating an account?

   

You have 1 free members-only resource remaining this month.

1 free members-only resources remaining

1 free members-only resources remaining

You've reached your limit of free insights

Become a member to access all of Advisory Board's resources, events, and experts

Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you.

Benefits include:

Unlimited access to research and resources
Member-only access to events and trainings
Expert-led consultation and facilitation
The latest content delivered to your inbox

You've reached your limit of free insights

Become a member to access all of Advisory Board's resources, events, and experts

Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you.

Benefits include:

Unlimited access to research and resources
Member-only access to events and trainings
Expert-led consultation and facilitation
The latest content delivered to your inbox

This content is available through your Curated Research partnership with Advisory Board. Click on ‘view this resource’ to read the full piece

Email ask@advisory.com to learn more

Click on ‘Become a Member’ to learn about the benefits of a Full-Access partnership with Advisory Board

Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you. 

Benefits Include:

Unlimited access to research and resources
Member-only access to events and trainings
Expert-led consultation and facilitation
The latest content delivered to your inbox

This is for members only. Learn more.

Click on ‘Become a Member’ to learn about the benefits of a Full-Access partnership with Advisory Board

Never miss out on the latest innovative health care content tailored to you. 

Benefits Include:

Unlimited access to research and resources
Member-only access to events and trainings
Expert-led consultation and facilitation
The latest content delivered to your inbox
AB
Thank you! Your updates have been made successfully.
Oh no! There was a problem with your request.
Error in form submission. Please try again.