August 2, 2021

$1,040 for 5 stitches? One patient's surprise bill exposes a legal 'gray area.'

Daily Briefing

    Although the No Surprises Act will ban most surprise medical bills, urgent care centers are not explicitly addressed in the legislation—leaving a gap where patients could be at significant risk for big bills, Rachana Pradhan writes for Kaiser Health News/NBC News.

    Radio Advisory: The biggest transparency and surprise billing policies coming your way

    'You do all the right things, ask all the right questions'

    Last November, Bryan Keller fell off his bike and dashed his head against the pavement, resulting in a cut on his forehead. Instead of heading to an ED, where he might have waited hours amid a spike in Covid-19 cases, Keller made his way to a nearby CityMD urgent care clinic to treat his injuries.

    At the clinic, staff told him a plastic surgeon would stitch up his forehead, something Keller thought strange considering it was an urgent care clinic. So, even in his "delirium" after the accident, Pradhan writes, Keller asked the staff several times if his health insurance would cover the procedure.

    According to Keller, the staff not only said it "'should be covered'" as "part of an emergency procedure," but that the plastic surgeon in question comes to the clinic "'all the time.'" But despite the staff's assurance, Keller was hit with a $1,039.50 bill for the five stitches he received from the plastic surgeon, who was an out-of-network physician working at the in-network urgent care clinic.

    "It really irked me that—it's this classic thing you hear in this country all the time," Keller said. "When you do all the right things, ask all the right questions, and you're still hit with a large bill because of some weird technicality that there's absolutely no way for you to understand when you're in the moment."

    Matt Gove, chief marketing officer at Summit Health, which owns CityMD, said the urgent care clinic's "normal procedure" is to "make the patient aware that this is available to them and that they can then make the choice as to whether or not it's important to them to be seen by a plastic surgeon."

    Ultimately, Keller said his health insurer, Aetna, rejected his appeal to fully cover the cost of his stitches.

    Urgent care facilities not covered under the No Surprises Act

    According to Pradhan, Keller's experience highlights the regulatory "gray area" of urgent care clinics under the forthcoming No Surprises Act, passed in December 2020 and scheduled to take effect in January 2022, which will ban most surprise medical bills. The law is intended to protect patients with private insurance from unexpected charges, including emergency out-of-network care, treatment from out-of-network providers at in-network facilities, and aerial ambulance transportation.

    However, Pradhan writes that urgent care centers, such as the one where Keller received his surprise bill, were not explicitly included in the No Surprises Act and may not be covered under the law. Recent interim regulations released by several federal agencies also have not included protections for patients being treated by out-of-network providers for non-emergency issues at in-network urgent care facilities.

    "You don't have protections if it turns out the doctor or the physician assistant was out of network," Jack Hoadley, a research professor emeritus at the McCourt School of Public Policy at Georgetown University, said.

    The gray area of urgent care centers

    According to Pradhan, the rules under the No Surprises Act have not been finalized, and HHS and three other federal agencies are looking into the frequency of surprise bills at urgent care centers as well as how health insurers contract with them.

    In addition, the Biden administration has shown an interest in including urgent care centers under the law, proposing a ban on surprise bills at urgent care centers licensed to perform emergency procedures. This proposal essentially categorizes urgent care centers as freestanding EDs, Pradhan writes.

    However, in most states urgent care centers are not encouraged to provide emergency procedures or even licensed as health care facilities. In fact, a report from Community Catalyst and the National Health Law Program in March found that fewer than 10 states issue health care facility licenses to urgent care centers—a situation that could stymie efforts to treat the facilities as freestanding EDs.

    In addition, Lou Ellen Horwitz, CEO of the Urgent Care Association, said urgent care centers are more akin to private physician offices than EDs or other hospital facilities. She added that the association would oppose any federal effort to classify urgent care centers as independent EDs or other health care facilities, saying doing so "contradicts" the purpose of urgent care, which is "to treat non-life-threatening injuries and illnesses."

    According to Pradhan, experts say that if this issue with urgent care centers is not addressed before the new law goes into effect next year, the gap in regulations could leave patients at risk.

    "There's a real interesting question about whether [the law] should apply to the extent that people perceive [urgent care centers] as places to go for an emergency," Hoadley said. (Pradhan, Kaiser Health News/NBC News, 7/29)

    Transparency and surprise billing

    The biggest policies coming your way

    Radio Advisory, a podcast for busy health care leaders.

    As Covid-19 begins to slow down in the United States, the health care world is starting to refocus on some of the issues that permeated the space before the pandemic. In this episode, Rae sits down with Advisory Board's Rob Lazerow and Heather Bell to talk about how three new policies—hospital price transparency, payer price transparency, and surprise billing—will affect the health care industry.

    Listen now

    Have a Question?

    x

    Ask our experts a question on any topic in health care by visiting our member portal, AskAdvisory.

    X
    Cookies help us improve your website experience. By using our website, you agree to our use of cookies.