Daily Briefing Blog

Health care's 'slowth' continues

Dan Diamond, Managing Editor

Is the health sector growing or shrinking? It only seems like the federal government can't make up its mind. 

Last month, the Bureau of Labor Statistics said that health care had lost jobs in January. But on Friday, the agency concluded that the sector actually grew by 6,500 jobs in January (and added another 9,500 jobs in February).

It's the third time in four months that the agency has reversed itself on whether or not health care has lost jobs, which points to a challenge in how the BLS collects its data: Agency economists rely on initial estimates that get finely tuned in subsequent months. (That point gets overlooked in most major headlines.)

But there's a bigger story here than month-to-month fluctuations. At this point, the issue isn't whether the BLS will report a small negative dip in the health care sector.

It's that health care's job growth has tightened up so much, a negative number wouldn't be a surprise.

That tightening can be seen in the chart above. And the data is telling a striking story about the past few months:

  • Across the past decade, the health care sector grew by about 23,000 jobs every month.
  • But between December 2013 and February 2014, the BLS projects the sector gained less than 18,000 total jobs. That's the slowest three-month period on record.

There's reason to be cautious about these latest figures—the 2014 data points are still just estimates, which means that the BLS's economists will update their headcount for January and February again.

However, there is a number we can be more confident about: BLS's 2013 data, which the agency has finalized. And those figures reinforce the broader trend of slowing growth or, forgive me, "slowth."

Specifically, while the industry is still booming compared to other sectors, the growth in health care jobs last year was the slowest since 1999.

And the chief culprit: the slowdown in hospital hiring, which began in earnest last summer.


Had hospital jobs grown at their traditional rates, 2013 would have been an average—or even banner—year for health care jobs growth. Instead, hospitals lost a slim 500 jobs in 2013, the sector's first down year since 1994.

In an upcoming blog post, I'll take a closer look at what's going on with hospitals and health care employment, and what the numbers are telling experts about broader industry trends.

How to get frontline staff to be more productive

Hospitals’ ability to improve cost and quality performance depends on staff at every level within the organization. But there is a troubling disconnect between expectations for the organization and those for frontline staff, Steven Berkow remarks.

Watch Steven's video to learn four key levers for driving shared responsibility and staff commitment to organizational success, then visit the frontline accountability topic page to browse the latest best practice research, expert guidance, webconferences, and more from across the Advisory Board.

Popular on the blog

Health spending is slowing. Jobs are growing. What gives?

One of health care's biggest mysteries: The cost curve is slowing. One of health care's biggest certainties: Jobs numbers keep growing. Read those two sentences again.

Half of office meetings are a waste of time. How to change that.

The science and strategy of having a great meeting, according to Harvard Business School, MIT, and Advisory Board research.

The surprise inside an 'astonishing' health care jobs chart

Overall, health care jobs are growing. But why is hospital job growth slowing down?

Tips to avoid the flu when you fly.

One of the most common spots for disease transmission? Aboard an airplane, warns the University of Arizona's Chuck Gerba.

Why Medicaid enrollment is surging in the exchanges

Take a closer look: Many of the early customers in the health insurance exchanges aren't signing up for private plans. Instead, they're enrolling in Medicaid.

If the Affordable Care Act had been struck down...

A world without the ACA is only a thought experiment today, but it didn't seem so hypothetical a year ago.

Which states will have the biggest coverage gaps next year?

Officials in California and Maryland both wanted to lead the nation on Obamacare implementation. But the president thinks a surprise state has "done best" at implementing his signature law.