In just one year, the number of EHR-related lawsuits doubled

Politico: Role of EHRs in malpractice cases remains 'modest'

Electronic health records (EHRs) are increasingly being cited in medical malpractice lawsuits, according to a review of data by the Doctors Company, a physician-owned medical malpractice insurer.

The review found that EHRs were involved in just 1% of a sample of lawsuits that had been closed between 2007 and 2013. However, the frequency of EHR-related lawsuits doubled between 2013 and 2014.

Medscape: Would 'Choosing Wisely' protect a doctor from a lawsuit?

According to Politico, the numbers of existing cases could be higher because it often takes up to six years to conclude a case.

Doctors Company Medical Director David Troxel says that while the percentage of EHR-related lawsuits remains comparatively low, "this is going to become a bigger and bigger issue."

Details of EHR-related lawsuits

According to Politico, the lawsuits alleged a variety of mistakes caused by EHRs, including:

  • Faulty voice-recognition software;
  • Misinterpretation of EHR drop-down menus;
  • Reliance on outdated or incorrect records; and
  • Typos that led to medical errors.

Further, some EHR systems are designed in a way that can prompt errors, according to Computerworld. For example, diagnosis drop-down menus can automatically enter data if a cursor hovers over a specific item for too long.

Why ‘workflow’ just became a health care buzzword (and why you should care)

Targets of lawsuits

According to Politico, health care professionals are typically the targets of such lawsuits because of contract agreements that exempt vendors from most legal liability under a "learned intermediary" doctrine. Such agreements are based on the idea that while information systems store the data and sometimes provide clinical decision support, the responsibility lies with the actual provider.

However, analysts predict that providers and health systems will start suing vendors, in part because of the potential to recover large sums in damages.

Keith Klein, a professor of medicine at the University of California-Los Angeles, says, "It's only a matter of time before a company like athenahealth or Allscripts or Epic or Cerner gets sued." According to Scot Silverstein, a health IT expert at Drexel University, lawyers are already considering such cases.

Inside malpractice lawsuits: Why so many doctors don't see them coming

Effect of EHR-related malpractice cases

According to Politico, the effect of EHRs on malpractice lawsuits remains "modest."

However, some analysts have expressed concern about the uncertainty that surrounds EHR data. According to Politico, EHR errors and inaccuracies could:

  • "[C]ast doubt" on physicians; and
  • Diminish clinical research that relies on large pools of data.

Michael Victoroff, a liability expert, said he believes the U.S. eventually will need a settlement fund to be drawn from to compensate for injuries to patients stemming from EHR-related cases (Allen, Politico , 5/4; Mearian, Computerworld, 4/13).

The takeaway: Recent data suggest that EHRs are becoming increasingly important components in malpractice lawsuits, but their effect remains "modest."


Next in the Daily Briefing

Kids vaccinated for whooping cough remain vulnerable during outbreaks

Read now