Understand how we got here — and how to move forward.


May 3, 2017

The health effects of your coffee habit are murky—but a fourth cup is probably OK

Daily Briefing

    The average American consumes about 300 milligrams of caffeine daily—but scientists know surprisingly little about when your next cup of coffee becomes unsafe, James Hamblin reports for The Atlantic.

    Your cup of joe won't give you cancer, WHO now says

    Caffeine isn't just a morning ritual—it's a drug used to do everything from reviving newborns to inducing seizures, Hamblin writes. But research is inconsistent on how many cups of coffee are one too many?

    One widely cited daily limit is 400 milligrams, which "comes from sources like [FDA] and the International Food Information Council," Hamblin writes. That's about one Starbucks Venti's worth. But caffeine is one of America's most consumed drugs, a single Venti isn't going to cut it for many people.

    What's more, not all cups of coffee are created equal in terms of caffeine, Hamblin writes—some companies are marketing hyper-strong coffee, with names like "Black Insomnia" and "Death Wish." Black Insomnia blows passed the 400-milligram cap, with a claimed 702 milligrams of caffeine in a 12-ounce cup. "That's around five times as much as a home-brew, and three times as much as Starbucks' dark roast," Hamblin writes.

    The range of caffeine-infused beverages prompted some researchers to question where the 400 milligram-cap comes from and whether it should be taken seriously.


    Esther Myers, a specialist in systematic research reviews at International Life Sciences Institute who has been examining the health effects of caffeine, sought to address that lack of evidence, looking at 700 studies in the most comprehensive review of caffeine safety to date to assess "whether adverse health effects occurred above, below, or at 400 milligrams.

    Based on their research, that 400-milligram cap is a safe maximum for healthy adults, but pregnant women should stay below 300 milligrams. "Above those levels the team found evidence of links to everything from depression and dysphoria (general unhappiness) to anxiety to hypertension to higher proportions of sperm with DNA damage," Hamblin says.

    However, Myers said the research doesn't mean 500 milligrams of caffeine is unsafe for everyone. "There's a great deal of inter-individual variability in how people respond to caffeine," she explained. "That's one of the research gaps. We need to better identify differences and identify people who are more sensitive."

    In fact, according to Hamblin, one of the main takeaways from Myers' research is that we know relatively little about the health effects of caffeine. For instance, "Myers' team highlights a particular need for a better understanding of how caffeine affects less-than-healthy adults" and "how the health effects of caffeine vary depending on how, when, and with what frequency it's consumed," he writes.  

    "So the best dose-guidance for now is this broad estimate about what not to do," Hamblin concludes. "For most people, 400 milligrams is almost certainly safe, but not necessarily good" (Hamblin, The Atlantic, 4/26).

    We can help you be more productive at work

    Video: Stop wasting time: Strategies to be more productive at work

    Infographic: The science—and strategy—behind having a 'great meeting'

    Webinar: Become an inbox ninja in 30 minutes

    Have a Question?


    Ask our experts a question on any topic in health care by visiting our member portal, AskAdvisory.